Skip to the cards
Subject
Nutrition
Filed
Source
James Williams
Loans
780

Do You Need Water on a Run Under 12 Miles? It Depends on Conditions

Josh Kerr’s 12-mile rule of thumb sparked debate, but distance alone can’t determine hydration needs. Weather, route access and personal needs matter.

Do You Need Water on a Run Under 12 Miles? It Depends on Conditions

There’s no universal distance below which runners can safely leave water behind. Josh Kerr’s suggestion that many people running fewer than 12 miles may not need to carry bottles is best read as a personal rule of thumb, not a hydration standard. The route, weather, pace, access to drinking water and a runner’s individual needs all affect the choice.

Two athletes embrace joyfully after a race, with other runners in the background.

Kerr, a Scottish middle-distance runner and world-record holder in the mile, made the comment during a Reddit question-and-answer session hosted by BBC Sport. He said city runners can often stop at a shop if they want a drink. The comment quickly drew responses from runners whose routes, safety concerns and running habits differ from his.

Sara Hall celebrating with fans, promoting her running playlist.

Distance is only one part of the decision

A 12-mile run can mean very different things depending on the person and conditions. A trained athlete may finish it faster than a beginner, while a slower pace can mean more time on the road. Heat can also make a run feel more demanding, and a route with long stretches between shops or fountains offers fewer easy opportunities to get water.

Keira D'Amato running with the text "Keira D'Amato's Running Playlist" overlaying the image.

That makes Kerr’s distance threshold a poor fit as a blanket recommendation. Someone running a short loop near reliable water access may be comfortable without carrying a bottle. Another person covering the same distance on a hot day, far from places to refill, may prefer to bring fluids. The number of miles alone can’t settle the question.

Harry Styles performing with fans at a concert, promoting his running playlist.

There’s also no single reason runners carry a vest, belt or handheld bottle. Some want water close by; others use the pockets to carry a phone or other belongings. In the social media discussion, one runner said she wore a belt partly to keep her phone with her in case of an emergency. That practical concern deserves consideration alongside hydration, especially when choosing a route or running alone.

Rachel Entrekins running playlist featuring an athlete in sunglasses on a nature trail.

Convenience can matter on longer outings

Carrying water has tradeoffs. A vest or belt that bounces, leaks or needs repeated adjustment can distract from a run. Stopping to buy a drink may interrupt a planned workout, and runners doing long training sessions may want fluids close by rather than depending on shops along the way.

Jess McClain sprinting with a focus, promoting her running playlist and TrackTown 2024 event.

Longer runs can also involve other fueling needs. The runner describing the debate said water is useful for swallowing energy gels during marathon training. That doesn’t mean every runner needs the same kit: it shows why advice based on one distance can miss the purpose of carrying supplies in the first place.

Headshot of Sean Abrams

Likewise, choosing to carry water doesn’t mean a runner is overprepared. For some, the equipment makes a route feel more manageable or provides a way to carry essentials. For others, the extra weight and movement are uncomfortable. Personal experience with a particular bottle or pack may help clarify whether its practical benefits outweigh the annoyance.

A useful rule of thumb has limits

Kerr’s comments came from the perspective of an elite athlete whose training experience is very different from that of many recreational runners. His view may resonate with people who run short distances in cities where water is readily available, but it doesn’t establish what other runners need. Beginners, slower runners and people exercising in hot weather may face different demands.

For a planned run, it can help to consider how long you expect to be out, whether drinking water is available along the route, and whether the conditions are unusually warm. A runner’s past experience and health needs matter too. Anyone uncertain about hydration because of a medical condition, medication or recurring symptoms can ask a doctor or pharmacist for advice tailored to their situation.

The practical takeaway is simple: 12 miles isn’t a reliable cutoff. Some runners will be comfortable carrying nothing on a shorter route; others will have good reasons to bring water, a phone or both. The most useful choice is the one that fits the conditions and makes the outing feel manageable.

Source: James Williams · www.runnersworld.com

Filed alongside